Last year, “Amazon employees met with ICE officials … to
market the company’s facial recognition technology,” the ACLU
informs us. Amazon VP Brad Huseman later
said “We believe the government should have the best
available technology.” Then, last month, Motherboard
revealed Amazon has partnered with police departments around
the country to create “a self-perpetuating surveillance
network” of Ring products.
Allow me to be the umpteenth to say: what the hell, Amazon?
tech employees, warehouse
employees, and customers are all protesting this marketing of
Rekognition to ICE, as well with the services provided by Amazon to
infamous Palantir. More than 500 Amazon tech employees, in
particular, have signed a letter of protest — but Amazon’s
leadership does not yet seem to be willing to engage with them in good faith.
Instead, Amazon has defended itself with a “Facts
on Facial Recognition with Artificial Intelligence” page, in
which they seem to think the only possible problem with their
technology is the possibility of false positives, and offer
halfhearted half-measures as “In all public safety and law
enforcement scenarios, technology like Amazon Rekognition should
only be used to narrow the field of potential matches … facial
recognition software should not be used autonomously.”
The technical concerns are real enough, as shown by Orlando’s
cancellation of their pilot Rekognition program. But I’m
tired of tech companies acting as if they have no responsibility to
the public beyond fixing their bugs and getting their tech working
as intended. Sometimes the intent itself is the problem.
“I feel that society develops an immune response eventually to
the bad uses of new technology, but it takes time,” Jeff Bezos
has said. Which is true as far as it goes. But a corollary is
that, in the interim, while society hasn’t developed immune
responses, we should be especially cautious about abuses. Another
is that the world’s wealthiest man should not abdicate his own
nontrivial part in optimizing society’s immune response. With
great power, they say, comes great responsibility.
The question is not really whether Rekognition’s technical
problems will be solved. The question is whether marketing it to
governments and law enforcement in order to enable ubiquitous
panopticon surveillance is good for any society in the world.
It’s dangerously intellectually lazy to say “if it’s legal it
must be OK” or “the institutions of democracy will protect us
from harm, therefore as a tech maven I don’t need to think or
worry about any consequences.”
In reality the law is extremely slow to react to new
technologies, and our institutions are increasingly sclerotic and
paralyzed — as much the tech industry will be all too eager to
tell you in other contexts. Relying on them for our “immune
response” is wilful negligence. Yes, technology is like fire, in
that it always can be used for both good and bad; but we are
rightfully far more cautious about fire in
tinderbox conditions than we are during the rainy season, and
we adjust our risk assessment accordingly. The unwillingness of
tech companies to accept their responsibility for the risks they
create is beyond worrying.
As I’ve said before, the only real, or at least real-time,
check on tech companies is their own employees. So it’s
heartening to see AWS employees push back against company policies
— and worrying, at best, to see Amazon refuse to engage with them
in good faith. The world expects better of Bezos and Amazon than
dodging important questions about the risks of their technologies
and passing them off as someone else’s department.
Facebook provides another cautionary tale. Hard as it may be to
believe now, not all long ago they were widely respected, trusted,
and even beloved. A backlash against companies like Amazon and
Facebook seems at first like few minor cavils from an extremist
fringe … but sometimes the pebbles of complaint suddenly
accumulate into a landslide of contempt. Let’s hope Amazon sees
the light before the techlash turns yet another erstwhile hero into
a thoroughly modern villain.
Source: FS – All Tech News 2
On the Amazon panopticon